Hey friends, and welcome back to the Kara Report podcast. I’m so glad you’re here. This topic has been on my ideas list pretty much since I launched the podcast, if I’m being honest. But Pinterest, like so many algorithms, has changed so much over the last two years. So I kept feeling like there was more I wanted to say, or that I was changing my mind a little bit about the platform.
Don’t get me wrong, I love the platform. This isn’t going to be anti-Pinterest. I do Pinterest management for a living, I believe in the power of the platform, and I use Pinterest to market my own business. But I do think it’s not for everyone. And I’m finding myself telling more and more business owners lately to wait — to wait until they’re ready, to wait until they can fully commit, to build some things up in their business first.
I thought I’d bring that conversation to the podcast today, because I do think the Pinterest algorithm is sort of recalibrating to what the landscape looks like post-AI. Anyway, let’s dive in.
Table of Contents
Is Pinterest marketing right for your business in 2026?
Okay, so today we’re talking about the Pinterest algorithm and specifically, whether it’s right for your business in 2026. And here’s the thing: I’ve kind of alluded to it in the intro already, but I run a Pinterest marketing agency. This is one of the key services that I sell.
And yet… I am telling more people to wait on Pinterest than I ever have.
So if you’ve been on the fence, or you’ve been feeling guilty about not doing it, or wondering if you’re missing out, I want you to settle in, because this episode is for you. And I promise I’m going to be really honest with you about all of it, including my own pricing and getting an ROI.
What Businesses Should Be On Pinterest To See An ROI?
I just feel like it’s worth saying: the easiest thing for me would be to tell everyone to do Pinterest, because it is what I sell and I know I can get results with it. However, the businesses I see getting real results — as in, more money in their bank account from people who find them on the Pinterest algorithm — do have specific things in place first. So I’m not the kind of person who’s going to recommend it for the sake of recommending it if I don’t feel like it’s going to serve you, and then just take your money and leave you feeling frustrated.
I’ve said many times on the podcast: “I don’t want your money if you don’t want to give it to me.” I feel so strongly about that. I only want happy money. So yeah, the honest answer to “is Pinterest right for me?” is: it depends. And I’m getting asked it a lot.
I also want to say, before I get into the meat of the episode: if you have a product-based business, you should be on Pinterest. Pinterest is visual, it’s searchable, it’s shoppable. They are leaning into e-commerce, and I feel like even though service-based businesses, who are primarily who I’m going to talk to in this episode, can greatly benefit from Pinterest it’s not really built for them. It’s built for bloggers, information businesses, creators, and e-commerce businesses. So if that’s you, Pinterest is for you.
But if you’re service-based, that’s where the nuance comes in.
Pinterest Role In Your Marketing Strategy
And most of the “should you or shouldn’t you” comes from the fact that I really don’t think people understand what Pinterest’s role is in your marketing strategy. I’ve said before that I believe Pinterest is a top-of-funnel-only marketing strategy.
feel like marketing people kind of throw these phrases around, so I’m going to take a second to explain it. Think of a funnel — wide at the top, narrow at the bottom.
Top of funnel is pure awareness — getting people to know you exist. (Outside the funnel entirely? That’s people who don’t even know you’re out there yet.) Once someone becomes aware of you — they follow you on Instagram, find your website, hear about you from a friend — they’ve entered the top of the funnel. They are not necessarily anywhere near a purchasing decision.
Middle of funnel is when they start to consider you. They’ve found you and they’re learning more: watching your stories, subscribing to your email list, opening your emails, doing their own research.
Bottom of funnel is when people are more ready to buy. They’re solution-aware, they’ve done their homework, and they’re ready to add to cart.
Pinterest marketing = top of funnel marketing
Pinterest introduces you to strangers — which means before Pinterest can work, there has to be somewhere for those strangers to go, otherwise they just float out of the funnel. They need somewhere to warm up to you and eventually convert.
So I know this sounds cliche, but: do you actually need more eyes right now, or do you need to convert the ones you already have? Because if you’re getting a hundred people to your website every month and not converting any of them, that’s unlikely to change once you’re getting a thousand, two thousand, three thousand people. Low conversion percentages are low conversion percentages.
The timeline to see an ROI on Pinterest marketing in 2026
And I think it’s worth talking about timeline: I have always said six to twelve months to see real momentum on the platform, and I still stand by that. HOWEVER…
Six to twelve months is how long it takes to get the platform to trust you (ie. the Pinterest algorithm we are all trying to impress). And what I’m seeing specifically in 2026 is that once people find you, they need more warming up than ever before.
There are longer purchase runways now. It used to be that someone might find you and make a buying decision within a month or two — maybe they’d find you during a launch and buy right then. We are not generally seeing that happen the same way anymore. People can follow you for a year before making a purchasing decision. They can follow you through several launches before they’re ready to invest.
That timeline matters when you’re putting money into something where the ROI isn’t immediate. Pinterest can absolutely help people find you but then those people also need to be in your orbit for a while before they’re ready to buy.
You need to be mentally prepared, not just financially prepared.
Long sales cycles are just part of how service-based businesses work right now, and I think that’s only going to continue for the next few years.
What I see people get wrong over and over is taking their foot on and off the gas pedal. They’re wondering where the results are by month two. They know going in that it takes six to twelve months but there’s still this undercurrent of “I’ve already paid for two months, where are my bookings?” It’s usually not something people say out loud. It’s more of a subconscious struggle.
And honestly? That inconsistency is more damaging than just waiting until you’re fully ready to commit.
This is part of why I recommend blogging so readily, not to compare the two platforms, but with a blog post, you can see the work. It’s on your site. You can share it. You get that sense of tangible progress that makes it easier to stay consistent even when you’re not seeing an immediate ROI. Pinterest just doesn’t give you that same feedback loop, and that’s worth naming before you invest.
Pinterest is not the easy platform it used to be.
When I started on Pinterest in 2017, it was simple. Create the graphic, keyword-stuff the description, stay semi-consistent — done. Remember group boards? Pinning other people’s content? It worked, and it wasn’t complicated.
That has changed significantly.
This is also why you need to be discerning when hiring someone for Pinterest management. I’ll speak only for myself: I took course after course over the years and kept feeling like they were all regurgitating the same information, and I wasn’t seeing consistent results, even in my own business. It was working for some accounts and not others, and I couldn’t figure out why, because I was doing exactly what every other Pinterest manager was doing.
It wasn’t until I found what I consider the best Pinterest marketing course out there (*affiliate link) — one that actually gets into what I’d call Pinterest code — that my perspective on the Pinterest algorithm completely shifted.
But most Pinterest managers aren’t doing what it actually takes to grow on Pinterest in 2026, and I was blind to it too. The platform got a reputation for being easy, and people are still operating like that — just create the graphic, add a title and description, drop it in Tailwind, pin it to multiple boards, and call it a day.
The Pinterest algorithm requires more strategy, more fresh content, more intentional optimization than it did a few years ago.
Start Thinking of Pinterest Like Instagram (In Terms of Effort Required)
I also want to relate this back to Instagram, because I think a lot of us think about social media — not with rose-colored glasses, exactly, but think about how much time and energy you’ve put into growing your Instagram. If you want to grow another platform seriously, it’s going to take the same level of effort, whether you outsource and pay or you spend your own time on it.
Lots of people come to me having had their Instagram account for five, ten years, and then I have to remind them that, “Oh, it’s only been three months on Pinterest.” I just want to remind people what it was like to start from scratch on social. It takes a long time.
And that’s not me trying to scare you off. I just feel like we need to be more realistic before taking on another platform — and that’s any platform, Pinterest, LinkedIn, any of them.
I think sometimes, as entrepreneurs, we are almost delusional about the amount of effort it takes to grow something new — and sometimes that works in our favor. But I see it a lot with Pinterest, where people are like, “I’m just going to add a new platform, it’ll be easy, it’ll take three months.” And it’s just not. It’s growing a whole other arm of your business.
I don’t think Pinterest is going anywhere. I think it’s a stable platform, growing in users, and incredibly effective. However, set it and forget it is just not a realistic Pinterest strategy anymore.
What You Should Do Before Investing in Pinterest Marketing in 202
Since Pinterest is a top-of-funnel platform, you need a functioning middle and bottom of funnel before it can actually work for you. Here’s what that looks like:
- A website that clearly explains what you do and who you help
- Blog content that Pinterest can point to (more on this in a minute)
- A real conversion process — a contact form, inquiry flow, discovery call — something that works for both a warm lead and a very cold one
That last point is worth sitting with. If you’re a website designer and someone finds you in their first year of business when they’ve got a Canva site up, you want to be the designer they call in year three when they have money. Pinterest can plant that seed — but only if your site and process are ready to receive it.
And one thing people often miss: your email list needs to convert too.
It’s not enough to send Pinterest traffic to a signup form if what follows is three generic welcome emails and then silence. If that’s happening, Pinterest didn’t fail you — your marketing did. Pinterest is essentially sending traffic to a leaky bucket. You’ll see more traffic, yes. But more customers? Not necessarily.
You need somewhere to continue the conversation after Pinterest — whether that’s your email list, your blog, or even Instagram. We’ve actually tried routing people from blog content to Instagram for some clients so they can warm up there before making a buying decision. It works!
A Majority of Pins Should Lead to Blog Posts
Pinterest users are primarily looking for blog content. It can work pointing to a YouTube video, a podcast episode, or a landing page — but it doesn’t work as well. The goal is to match people’s expectations. If you’re leading somewhere that isn’t a blog post, you need to make that really clear on the graphic itself, otherwise you’ll see high bounce rates — which is a negative signal to Pinterest and slows your growth.
If you can’t afford both blogging and Pinterest, start with blogging
This is probably the question I get most often, in some version: “Can I blog on my own and hire you for Pinterest? Can we do a light package of each? Can we make my budget work?”
My answer is always the same: start with blogging.
Here’s why. Blogging lives closer to the middle and bottom of funnel. Yes, there’s some top-of-funnel SEO action, but blogging is typically where people land when they’re searching for something specific — so it has a stronger conversion component built in. When you’re blogging well, you’re showing your expertise, giving people a sense of who you are, and naturally leading them toward working with you or joining your list.
There’s also a very practical reason: the Pinterest algorithm needs content to pin to. I can’t tell you how many times someone has hired me for Pinterest management, sworn they’re going to keep up with blogging, and then… it just doesn’t happen. Which means I’m recycling the same five posts from month one over and over. That’s not everyone — some clients absolutely do maintain their blog — but it’s common enough that I always flag it upfront.
When I’m managing both blogging and Pinterest, the whole strategy works better. The content is connected, the workflow is tighter, and we can do more with things like seasonal content. It’s also why my pricing reflects a discount when you do both together — it’s more effective, not just more convenient.
What does Pinterest management actually cost in 2026?
Since I think pricing is helpful context when you’re deciding whether Pinterest is the right next move, here’s where my services stand right now:
- Blogging: $500/month
- Pinterest management: $850/month
- Pinterest and Blogging: $1,000/month
Pinterest management is higher on its own because there’s significantly more content management involved when I’m not also handling the blogging. When I’m running both, I get into a much more efficient workflow — which is why the bundled price reflects a real discount, not just a slight one.
Here’s a practical way to think about it:
If you have a $5,000 budget and you’re ready to invest in search-driven marketing, that gets you ten months of blogging or about six months of Pinterest. For most service-based businesses that are still building their foundation, ten months of blogging is the safer bet. You’ll see more momentum, faster, for the same investment.
Once that foundation is solid, adding Pinterest on top becomes a very different kind of investment — because now it has somewhere to land. I call Pinterest the cherry on top, and I mean that genuinely. It can bring in a ton of clients and build incredible visibility. But the cherry works best when there’s something underneath it.
Do you offer a smaller Pinterest package?
I get this question a lot: “What if I just do something light? I don’t want to go all in, but I don’t want to do nothing.”
I do offer a light Pinterest package at $250/month, by request, and I want to be straightforward about what it is and isn’t. It’s designed for maintenance — keeping your profile active, getting pins indexed, having some presence on Google.
In an AI search world where showing up in multiple places matters more than ever, even light activity has value. Pinterest pins create backlinks to your site, which supports your SEO, and that’s great.
But it is not enough to grow your Pinterest account in 2026, and it is not going to fill your inbox with leads. If someone comes to me wanting the light package because they’re hoping it’ll drive new business, I tell them the truth: maybe eventually, but it will take much longer than a full investment, and that’s not really what this package is designed for. I’m cautious about who I sell it to, because I’d rather be honest upfront than have you frustrated two months in.
Not Every Business Needs To Be On Pinterest in 2026
If you’re still figuring out your offer or messaging — wait.
If your website isn’t converting the traffic you’re already getting — wait.
If you can’t commit to consistency for the long haul right now — wait.
If you’ve been doing it halfheartedly and feeling guilty about it, you can stop.
And if the idea of full commitment feels scary and you’re thinking about doing a little of everything — consider just starting with blogging, or another search-driven platform, and doing it well. None of this means Pinterest won’t be right for you eventually. I’d just so much rather you come to it ready.
So who should move forward with Pinterest?
- You have a clear offer, a website that converts, and blog content already in place
- You’ve hit a ceiling on referrals and need a new visibility channel
- You’re ready to think in terms of one to two years, not months
- You want marketing that works while you’re not working — evergreen, compounding, search-based
- You understand this is a real investment, not a side task
If that’s you, Pinterest is a serious contender for your marketing dollars in 2026. I genuinely mean that. I don’t want this to read as a warning against Pinterest — it’s one of the best long-game visibility tools available for service businesses that are ready for it. “Ready” just has a specific definition: a solid content foundation, a backend that converts, and the mental commitment to stay consistent even when results feel slow.
If you’re not there yet, that’s okay.
Start with blogging. Build the foundation. Come back to Pinterest when it has somewhere to land.
I say that as someone who sells Pinterest management for a living — and I mean every word of it. There’s no shame in taking it off your list for now if your business isn’t in the right place for it. The goal is marketing that actually works, not marketing that adds to the overwhelm.
You know where to find me when you’re ready: thekarareport.com
LINKS MENTIONED
- Hire us to write SEO-driven blog posts for you
- Learn more about our Pinterest management services
- Learn more about working with our marketing agency here
- The best Pinterest marketing course in 2026
- Follow me on Instagram
